Maxspect Mazarra P, the Full Review

By on Dec 15, 2011

reef aquarium led light

I recently shared the unboxing of Maxspect’s latest LED offering, the Mazarra P series. Well here’s the review. I’ve recently replaced the metal halide/T5 fixture over my 180 -gallon with the Mazarra modules. The minimum number of modules for a 6 foot tank should probably be 4, with an sps-dominant tank probably better off with 6 of them. I decided to start with 3. I plan to add 2 more, but money is tight with Christmas around the corner.

reef aquarium led light

To recap, the Mazarra P series consists of 60-watt modules, housing a variety of LEDs. One of the unique aspects of the Mazarra is the ball-joint mounting arm and light rail. The other cool feature is the ability to swap out individual LED chips with a screwdriver.

reef aquarium led light

This is how the tank looked using metal halide and T5 tubes

INSTALL:
The rail mounting system offers a variety of ways to position the lights over your tank. I really wanted to use the tank mount brackets, but they will only work on trim up to .78″ thick. The trim on the 180-gallon was clearly too wide. I think the brackets are designed with rimless tanks in mind. It would be nice to see a bracket compatible with wider trim. My Metal Halide fixture was suspended from the ceiling, and I decided to do the same with the Mazarras. Fortunately, the wire suspension uses the same ceiling anchor as my old light. All I had to do was adjust the light rail to line the wires up with the old anchors. The main rails attach to each other via smaller rails inside. Therefore, you can slide the outer rails to the correct length, and tighten the screws to clamp down on the smaller attachment rails… Easy as pie.

reef aquarium led light

SETUP:
Starting with only 3 modules, I opted to use 100 degree optics for improved spread. Even with the wider optics, using 3 modules is a stretch to illuminate an entire 6-foot aquarium. However, you could easily modify your aquascape to work with the limited spread. Reefs with minimalist aquascapes could pull it off. LEDs provide a very focused source of light, and therefore you could illuminate individual coral “bommies”, and leave dramatic shaded areas for low light corals. Glass scraping and other algae issues would be easier to manage as well. In my tank, I have two large rock islands. I think 2 modules per island would probably suffice.

reef aquarium led light

The onboard controls are handy if you choose to forgo the wireless controller. But you are stuck choosing one intensity level for each channel, and will need to rely on an appliance timer. I think the Mazarras really shine with the wireless controller. You can simply set the time, and choose the default time phase program. It will ramp up/down the various LED channels according to time off day along 8 time points. In the wee hours, it leaves some of the blue LEDs at 1-2%, to simulate moonlight. Alternatively, you can also create your own time phase, and choose your own intensities per channel at 8 time points. With multiple modules, you can also add a dawn/dusk mode. This feature simulates the sun rising and setting over the horizon of your tank. Lastly, it lets you add a little weather for fun. You can choose the frequency of clouds, which it simulates by briefly dimming the modules individually over the span of your tank.

The Mazarras are engineered for passive cooling, therefore the fans come unattached. The manual describes the fans as being optional, in cases where the modules are in a confined space(like a canopy). Even though my install is open aired, I still chose to run the fans. The fans are extremely quiet, consume very little electricty, and probably improve LED longevity further. So why not?

reef aquarium led light

BUILD QUALITY:
The design and functionality are exceptional. But what about the quality? I ran into two issues. The first was some missing screw holes in the ball-joint arms. These holes accomodate screws to keep the mount in the same position on the rail with friction. They aren’t really necessary, as there is enough friction to keep things in place. This is a brand new product, so there may be some wrinkles to address. I also had one module not illuminating the D-Channel of LEDs. CoralVue and Maxspect were quick to respond, and helped me figure out the cause. The Actinic UV chips are more delicate to solder, and can be easily damaged with pressure. Once we identified the problem, Chris quickly shipped out a new set of them free of charge.  I’m sure they would’ve rectified the missing screw holes as well, but it wasn’t a big deal for me. In my opinion the support was thorough and quick.

IMPRESSIONS:
While I dig the the ability to angle the light, I think my favorite aspect is the quality of light spectrum. I’ve seen my share of LED reef lighting, and I deemed many of them to produce a very artificial and sterile light quality. I attribute it to the fact that most fixtures stick to cool white LEDs to compliment the blue. Maxspect’s inclusion of warm whites and purple actinic LED chips significantly improve the spectrum. Coming from 14K halides, I think the Mazarras produce a very familiar light spectrum. To me, they resemble the Phoenix 14k bulbs.

reef aquarium led light

As far as the transition from metal halides into LED, I have no regrets. My tank runs 8 points cooler at 75 degrees with the Mazarras. The halides also produced a lot of light spillage. Not only did it light up the space around the tank, it also blinded my 1 year old daughter(from her viewing angle). A canopy would have resolved the glare, but it’s nice to have an open tank without light bleeding everywhere. My sps have been growing well, even with just 3 modules. After my planned addition of two more, I’m only running 300-watts of light versus almost a 1000-watts of metal halide/T5. While I’m sure a PAR meter would tell me the intensities aren’t comparable, I would argue that my reef never really needed as much light as I was giving it. I used to run the same tank with 468-watts of T5, and grew beautiful Acropora colonies. I feel confident I can do the same with a similar wattage of LEDs.

CONCLUSION:
Overall, I’m very pleased with the Mazarras. The positives far outweigh some small issues I experienced. The quality of light it produces in the tank is exceptional. The modularity and variety of mouting options make for a very adaptable lighting system. It can grow or shrink with you as you upgrade/downsize tank sizes. The optional fans are borderline silent. And I can’t think of many fixtures that include a variety of optics and easily interchangeable LED chips. I look forward to trying other LED colors in the modules as they become available. Lastly, product support appears to be good from both the manufacturer and their US distributor(CoralVue).

If there are any questions that I can help answer, leave a comment and I’ll do my best to answer.

FTC regulations require that we inform you that we were given this product for review, but our opinion of a product is never affected by how we acquire them.

reef aquarium led light
reef aquarium led light

Posted in Reef News |
Search More:  
   
  • Vitaliy Pysmennyy

    So Glad I went with these :)  awaiting shipment tomorrow!  Great review!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Bobby-Thom/100001344399237 Bobby Thom

    thanks for the great review

  • http://www.aquariumspecialty.com Scott G

    Our Mazarra stock order will be here on Monday.  

    http://www.aquariumspecialty.com/lighting/led-lighting/maxspect-led-lighting

  • http://www.aquariumspecialty.com Scott G

    Our Mazarra stock order will be here on Monday.  

    http://www.aquariumspecialty.com/lighting/led-lighting/maxspect-led-lighting

  • http://twitter.com/tbaquatics TB Aquatics

    we’ve got them in stock. http://www.tbaquatics.com

  • Anonymous

    i like the tank spectrum better with the first photo,the cords hanging out the back of those mazarra looks bodgy.
    the corals on the far right side are missing light also.IMO the intensity is lacking and the units should be of higher wattage and greater coverage for the price paid

  • Anonymous

    i like the tank spectrum better with the first photo,the cords hanging out the back of those mazarra looks bodgy.
    the corals on the far right side are missing light also.IMO the intensity is lacking and the units should be of higher wattage and greater coverage for the price paid

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VP2AH2FX2HF2VF2HM7RRHIWDDY Chipper

    No thanks.

    Like most LEDs, they will lack growth and color after 2 years of use.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VP2AH2FX2HF2VF2HM7RRHIWDDY Chipper

    No thanks.

    Like most LEDs, they will lack growth and color after 2 years of use.

  • http://www.facebook.com/ben.leikin Ben Leikin

    I can make statements too without any evidence to back it up.

  • http://www.facebook.com/ben.leikin Ben Leikin

    I can make statements too without any evidence to back it up.

  • Anonymous

    Can’t believe there’re still skeptics on LED around these days, if this was posted on 2008 I would understand but in 2011?

    Do some search online and you’ll find there’re plenty of very successful SPS tanks that were kept under LED for over 2 years.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VP2AH2FX2HF2VF2HM7RRHIWDDY Chipper

    One of MANY people who have had problems with their LED fixtures.  Here’s your 50,000 hour light:

    http://reefcentral.com/forums/showpost.php?p=19317422&postcount=132

    Yeah, Jimmy….”Skeptics”

    That enough proof for you Ben……

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VP2AH2FX2HF2VF2HM7RRHIWDDY Chipper

    One of MANY people who have had problems with their LED fixtures.  Here’s your 50,000 hour light:

    http://reefcentral.com/forums/showpost.php?p=19317422&postcount=132

    Yeah, Jimmy….”Skeptics”

    That enough proof for you Ben……

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VP2AH2FX2HF2VF2HM7RRHIWDDY Chipper

    One of MANY people who have had problems with their LED fixtures.  Here’s your 50,000 hour light:

    http://reefcentral.com/forums/showpost.php?p=19317422&postcount=132

    Yeah, Jimmy….”Skeptics”

    That enough proof for you Ben……

  • http://www.facebook.com/ben.leikin Ben Leikin

    Hardly enough to completely dismiss a technology.

    How about this? http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2065954

    There’s also literally dozens of other success stories compared to that one thread.

  • http://www.facebook.com/ben.leikin Ben Leikin

    Hardly enough to completely dismiss a technology.

    How about this? http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2065954

    There’s also literally dozens of other success stories compared to that one thread.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VP2AH2FX2HF2VF2HM7RRHIWDDY Chipper

    One thread?  A thread that was started 3 MONTHS AGO!!! LOL…..

    What was my initial point – “Like most LEDs, they will lack growth and color after 2 years of use”

    Do some research rookie.

    A TEK light with the right bulbs in it will blow this junk away… So would an ATI fixture. So would a SLS pendant.

    But, you are a newbie Ben and go for whatever is trendy.

  • Mark van der Wal

    The post you are referencing are from first generation AI’s. To use the first generation of a specific product to make a generalized comment about all LED’s is misleading. Improper cooling could have attributed to the issues in your link. I’d be interested,with an open mind, to read the other dozen threads that report having drops in intensity so quickly. The 50,000 hour ratings are definitely a bit of marketing, since running the LED’s at 100% would never get you such longevity. Everyone knows expecting 10 years is a bit unrealistic. Nevertheless, I could replace all the led chips on 4-5 Mazarra modules for around $400 if I had to in 5-8 years. The all-T5 fixture and the MH/T5 fixture both averaged around $300/yr in bulb replacement on my 180g.

  • Mark van der Wal

    The cord situation is my own doing. I intend to add 2 more modules, and I didn’t want to organize the cords out one side until I have the new ones installed. I’m definitely pushing the limits running only 3 units over 6 feet. For an sps tank, you’d want double that. This is a 60-watt module for $400. I don’t think the pricing is off, compared to competitor products. The AI is $400 for 72-watts. They are both great units. The AI offer more wattage for the price, while the Mazarras offer a larger variety of LED’s and some onboard dimming and fan control. I’d honestly be happy with either. The Radions are double the wattage, but run $750 or so.

  • Mark van der Wal

    The cord situation is my own doing. I intend to add 2 more modules, and I didn’t want to organize the cords out one side until I have the new ones installed. I’m definitely pushing the limits running only 3 units over 6 feet. For an sps tank, you’d want double that. This is a 60-watt module for $400. I don’t think the pricing is off, compared to competitor products. The AI is $400 for 72-watts. They are both great units. The AI offer more wattage for the price, while the Mazarras offer a larger variety of LED’s and some onboard dimming and fan control. I’d honestly be happy with either. The Radions are double the wattage, but run $750 or so.

  • Anonymous

    replacing all the LEDs by the time they start running 70% won’t cost anywhere near $400 – that’s more like today’s replacement cost. 

  • Anonymous

    replacing all the LEDs by the time they start running 70% won’t cost anywhere near $400 – that’s more like today’s replacement cost. 

  • Mark van der Wal

    Jake, you’re right, I just saw the pricing on the chips today. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Aaron-Bailey/1217730233 Aaron Bailey

    How many of these do you expect would be needed for a 4 foot 55 gallon tank with SPS corals?

  • http://www.facebook.com/robin.lutchman Robin Lutchman

    You seem to be the rookie Chipper, You can’t compared different company products to others its like saying a hyundai is built like a ferrari, or a Tunzie pump is like a Hydor…which most EXPERIENCED saltwater enthusiast know they are not at all they may move water but thats the only thing they have in common.

    If we all had your perspective we all would still be running canister filters for our reefs and calling Apitasia infested rocks good stuff for your reef, and hair algae really cool to. lol.

    Now that more and more companies has emerged for Led lighting, you will see more and more positive reviews and major improvements most likely in the programming modules.

    I saw a first gen Maxspect going for apron 2 years now, and the coral are beautiful and growth is there. I have also seen the new mazzara and thats going to be my next purchase, I am decades from a beginner,and have had my share of trials with Metal Halide lighting, heat, chiller, hydro bill ,bulb change frequency,and additional lighting supplementation to welcome the led tech.

  • http://www.facebook.com/robin.lutchman Robin Lutchman

    I will be getting 5 for a 265g which is 7 feet long and add a sixth one afterwards.

    In your case with the tank being 4′ I would go no less than 2 with the 100degree lens,and 3 being the best for SPS dominated setup.

    I also will recommend not using the preset program at first. I saw a tank have its SPS burn with the intensity of these lights,he had to reduce the power out put to a custom setting in the beginning 65/100/100/65 now everything is coming around nicely but it took some time for the SPS to recover from the shock.

  • http://www.facebook.com/robin.lutchman Robin Lutchman

    I just got my new Mazzaras new ball joint knuckles,ballast that is cul approved real sweet!

  • http://www.facebook.com/ellery.wong Ellery Wong

    Mark, Now after 6 months any updates on your Mazzara P series?