2011 Aquarium LED lighting showdown — we’ll let you decide

By on Jan 03, 2012

 

Looking back at our posts in 2011 we can definitely see the effect of LED lighting in the aquarium market, proving to be one of the hottest topics we covered this past year. With so many new products hitting the market, we thought we’d pick out a good chunk of them and let you decide the best, new aquarium LED lighting product of 2011 –”LED Madness” tournament style!

We picked our 32 top stories on new aquarium LED lighting that appeared in 2011 and paired them up in our first ever Reef Builders reader’s choice tournament bracket (click here for a full-size image of the bracket)  Just like picking your March Madness bracket, instead of Michigan over San Jose State you vote on which of the two LED lights you like better. We will tally up the voted and the winner will advance to the next round, eventually giving us the top LED light of the year chose by you, our incredible readers.

Here is Round 1 with voting that will close at 12:00 p.m. (PST) on 04, January 2012.

Current USA Trulumen Pro vs. Reef Brite XHO LED 

This showdown features two strips, with the Current USA Trulumen Pro and the Reef Brite XHO LED. The versatility of the Trulumen Pro with all its colors or the power of Reef Brite XHO, this is definitely a tough call!

 

Eco-Lamps KR93 Full Spectrum vs. Sfiligoi Genesis

The Eco-Lamps Full Spectrum LED is trying to tackle a problematic area in LED lighting around having a full light spectrum represented. The Sfligoi Genesis is using the modular approach giving you the option to mix and match to get the full spectrum look with upgradability to RGB LEDs.

 

Maxspect Mazarra vs, TMC MiniLED 400

This one may be a David vs. Goliath but will the robust features of the Maxspect Mazarra stand up to the TMC MiniLED 400? Look over the features and how these best fit their intended markets to decide this one.

 

Ecoxotic Panorama Pro vs. Eheim Aqualight

The Ecoxotic Panorama Pro is definitely more robust, has more colors than the previous generation and even has an RGB version. The Eheim Aqualight is a nice little light that is hitting more in the daylight section but it is worth a look for planted aquariums or refugiums.

 

Sunbrite Slimline S vs. EcoRay LED

The Sunbrite Slimline S is a sleek looking fixture, tri-color LEDs, has a great price and oh yeah, a remote control! The EcoRay LED does have a narrow LED lens but is that enough to hold it back?

 

Pacific Sun Metis Hypereon vs. Blue Moon Aquatics P30

The Pacific Sun Metis Hyperion definitely is setting the bar high with Cree XM-L and UV LEDs in a sleek and stylish fixture. Blue Moon Aquatics P30 is a great combination pendant with a Multics LED to boot!

 

Kessil A150W vs. CadLights LED

The Kessil A150W is definitely one pendant to keep your eye on — different colors, proprietary chips and a great price! CadLights LED has some nice touches on LEDs with a two-channel, a nice price and different sizes.

 

Ecotech Radion XR30 vs. Arcadia Eco-Aqua 30W

The Ecotech Radion XR30 hit the LED with plenty of buzz and so far the reviews have been pretty favorable for the XR30 as Ecotech Marine starts venturing out more. The Arcadia Eco-Aqua looks pretty promising too, will its simplicity win out over the XR30′s features?

 

Sfiligoi Astra vs. Pharos LED

The Sfiligoi Astra is a sleek and slim looking fixture for smaller aquariums or using a few over a larger tank. For those of you looking for clean aesthetics in your light, this is one to look at. The Pharos LED is taking the black box light fixture to a whole new level and hopefully will create some more innovation on top of the “Chinese box.”

 

Vertex Illumilux vs. Innovative Marine Skkye LED

The Vertex Illumilux is a nice, modular strip with impressive construction we were quite impressed with when we got our hands on it. Innovative Marine Skkye Light LED is an interesting clamp on fixture coming in three different powers making it a versatile choice for nano tanks.

 

Ecoxotic Panorama Retro 2D vs. Lucenova HydroLED

The Ecoxotic Panorama Retro 2D is a great way to add LED lighting to your existing canopy or to use as a hanging light. The great feature now is the ability to dim these lamps. The Lucenova HydroLED is sleek and futuristic looking and definitely has the eye appeal.

 

JBJ Unibody LED vs. AquaticLife LED

The JBJ Unibody LED is a great direction the company is taking to take the manufacturer beyond just the casual hobbyist. New refinements have made the light even better. AquaticLife LED ventured into the modular LED market with these new strips that are definitely worth a look.

 

Pacific Sun Galileo vs. Ecoxotic 120W Cannon

The Pacific Sun Galileo is compact and loaded with Cree XP-G LEDs making it perfect for your nano setup. Taking heat management to a whole new level, the Ecoxotic 120W Cannon has more power and is lighter thanks to efficient use of heat pipes to aid in cooling.

 

NanoBox vs Acan Lighting A207

The NanoBox is one nice looking modular, entry-level fixture with four controllable channels of light plus active cooling. The Acan Lighting A207 is a nice supplemental lighting strip with enough power to add some nice blue to your tank.

 

AquaIllumination Nano vs. CoraLED

The AI Nano is one that sets the bar pretty high no matter if its a nano or a full-sized fixture. Streamlined and refined, we were impressed with the final release version of the AI Nano. Coming from across the pond, the CoraLED is an interesting new company from the UK that will even build you a 10 ft. version if you’d like.

 

 Evolution LED vs. Illumagic Blaze Advance LED

The Evolution LED from ReefKoi is a nice step up from the black box with 2W LEDs with two shades each of white and blue and totally dimmable. Illumagic Blaze Advance LED light now includes more action in the blue end of the light spectrum including ultraviolet (UV) LEDs in

 

 

Posted in Equipment |
Search More:  
   
  • Anonymous

    no AI Sol?  you left off the best one!

  • Anonymous

    AI Sol was introduced several years ago, this poll is targeted at newer LEDs of 2011. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/Tank2379 Frankie Torres

    It’s only Round 1

  • http://www.facebook.com/beau.snyder Beau Snyder

    Without the AI Sol (even though it was introduced years ago) I don’t think it is a fair evaluation really since it is one of the most used and best on the market. I predict the Ecotech Radion will easily win against all these since the AI Sol isn’t playing.

  • http://www.reefbuilders.com Brian Blank

    Beau, sure there are plenty of AI Sol out there but this is just a ramped up readers choice poll of products released in 2011. We are not evaluating the LED market by what’s the most popular overall, just looking at the products we saw in 2011.

  • Anonymous

    I dig the creative post and voting.  Nice work guys.

  • Anonymous

    Doesn’t mean the SOL will magically appear in round 2……..

  • http://www.facebook.com/kreeger1 Erik Kreeger

    yeah major mistake on no ai sol blue.   Poll means nothing now

  • likeagrouse

    Let’s GO NANOBOX!!

  • likeagrouse

    Nanobox is incredible… Nuff said…

  • Anonymous

    This is how I see the final battle, EcoTech Radion vs Maxspect Mazarra with the Radion winning.

    (btw RB, you spelled Radion as Radian in your chart)

  • Jon Hahn

    You guys should do a poll like this for all of the PAR38/30 bulbs out there.  I used to only think of a few off the top of my head, but there are actually a couple dozen “reef ready” PAR38′s out there.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1065211558 Jason Kramer

    Should have Apollo on there.  Probably didn’t pay to have their product shilled.  I mean reviewed.  Most people voting have no experience with this many fixtures.  We all know that Radion will win due to name recognition and not actual validity.  

  • http://twitter.com/AwItsLinnikins Linny

    This is nothing more than a high school popularity contest..

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Johnny-Ciotti/100000442770484 Johnny Ciotti

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=704609972 Julian Wilson

    Where’s the Orphek unit, i love mine, so glad i replaced my halides. I know they probably won’t get on the list due to a certain persons actions but that shouldn’t matter really. This poll is a waste of time as most people will vote for lights they haven’t even used. One over here in the UK and everyone voted for the Radion even though it wasn’t even released! LOL

  • http://twitter.com/clownfishman Hubert CLOWNFISHMAN

    frankly, this is just a popularity and marketing effectiveness contest :)   How many of us out there can we say we have tried more than half of these LOL 

  • http://twitter.com/Martin_Brochu Martin Brochu

    Most products are against products aimed at totally different solution like nano’s, this is not comparing apple to apple. This is ridiculous! You have a great blog, but this wasn’t a good idea… I’d pull it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/ewgroth Eric Roth
  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4FVXKOUOOYXEOPKO4Y3PK2JCRI J.T.

    You, sir, win.  +1 internets to you!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XMBVIE5PJXMAMZJSENESFNWBKA Joe

    Looks like you called it right from day 1.