It’s Back! 2012 LED Showdown — You Decide

By on Jan 14, 2013

The Reef Builders LED showdown is back! Last year we had a lot of fun letting you choose who you thought was the “top dog” in the LED showdown and wanted to let you all have the chance to weigh in on who you think should be named the top LED light of 2012. We wish we could line them all up and let them perform side-by-side to let you all chose, but we can’t do that so instead we will let you share your opinion on who you’d put over your corals in a head-to-head bracketology smackdown. Just like last year, we decided to lay it out March Madness style. We did our best to have a balanced bracket with a good selection and variety of lighting options in each pool. The method is simple — you vote on which of the two lights you like in each head-to-head poll and the winner will advance. Whatever light makes it through the gauntlet will earn honors as the 2012 Reef Builders LED Showdown Champion. The initial set of polls are open until 11:59 p.m. PST on Thursday, January 17. We decided to make this all about lights that were not only introduced in 2012, but began shipping in 2012. You will notice a few lights may not be mentioned because we had covered them in the 2011 contest.

led showdown 2012 rd1

Econolux SolarStinger NanoFlex/Cluster LED vs. Kessil A350/A350W Spotlight
The Econolux SolarStinger NanoFlex and Cluster LED have Econlux’s rainbow cluster LED, are passively cooled and have flexible mounting options including tank and side mounts are available in both freshwater and marine configurations.The Kessil A350 and Kessil A350W are powerful spotlight pendants with multiple LED colors, two channels of manual control, inaudible active cooling and a great price.

Vertex Illumina 260, 320, 360 vs. Reef Breeders 144W
Vertex Illumina 260, 320, 360 packed in CREE XTE diodes separated specifically by binning targeting different performance levels in three upgraded and high-performance models. The Reef Breeders 144W uses a modular design, has full controls through both a remote and an on fixture controller and a built in timer.

Coralife Aqualight LED vs. CadLights Multichip LED
Coralife Aqualight LED comes with a built in controller, some degree of color control and is loaded with Cree XP-sized LED chips in both blue and white. Coming in 30, 50 and 100W flavors, the CadLights Multichip LED feature built in timers and dimming controls of the supplemental LEDs and includes remote which also helps in programming the  lights.

Schuber Wright LED vs. Tunze LED Strip Lights
Schuber Wright LED  4W spotlight has an attractive side mounting arm and comes in an actinic blue color with a desirable low wavelength peak between 439 and 456 nm or a white color with an 8000K color temperature. The Tunze LED strip lights are waterproof with magnetic mounts with two channels of LEDs which will be independently controllable with the Tunze multicontroller.

AcanLighting Prism vs. GHL Mitras LX 6100
The AcanLighting Prism LED is a veritable cornucopia of different LED colors with more than eight colors of LEDs AcanLighting Prism has three channels of color control. GHL Mitras LX 6100 LED packs some serious punch, featuring nine separate dimmable channels of multicolor LED lighting. An on board controller allows the user to modify settings on the fixture and a USB interface for advanced programming.

Panorama Marine/Actinic LED vs. AquaLighter LED Nano and Striplights
The Panorama Marine LED and Panorama Actinic LED come in longer lengths and are a solid option for longer tanks. THe simple, yet powerful strips are equipped with a single long common reflector, tank mounting brackets and retrofit kit to fasten them into a canopy. The AquaLighter LED Striplights and AquaLighter LED Nano are some neat lights from the Ukraine that offer a nice looking, affordable light in freshwater and marine flavors.

StarkLED BluNova vs. Sunbrite F-Series
The StarkLED BlueNova has built wireless capability and control with three LED arrays of CREE XM-L Cool White, XP-E Blue and Royal Blue 5W LEDs all running at 5 watts. The SunBrite F-Series V1 and SunBrite F-Series V2 are both WiFi enabled that is fully controllable via an iphone app and has an array of Cree, Osram and UV LEDs. The V2 offers individual reflectors.

Blau Nano vs. Elos Elite 3
Small and sleek with two channels of LED control, the Blau Nano features feature 36 white LEDs and 24 blue LEDs and is an affordable option for smaller tanks. The Elos E-Lite 3 features customization and upgrade-ability options with interchangeable tops for easy color matching with your room and features replaceable LEDs.

Finnex Siriya LED vs. AquaIllumination Vega Color/Vega Blue
The Finnex Siraya LED fixture sports three Schuber Wright AC LED spotlights, yup AC not DC LEDs that run cooler and more efficient than a DC spotlight. The AquaIllumination Vega Color and Vega Blue lights each have 20 channels of control independently of the others with wireless control.

Maxspect Mazzarra X vs. E.Shine Aquasun
The E.Shine AquaSun has 36 LEDs featuring a 50/50 mixture of Cree XP-E Royal Blues and XP-G Cool Whites with built in timer and controller to dial in the light to suit your needs. The Maxspect Mazzarra X is a big step up for the other Mazzarra models with full-spectrum lighting and a built in controller of the Master unit.

Sicce Minu LED vs. Pacific Sun Triton R2
The Sicce Minu LED has 72 cool white LEDs and 4 royal blue LEDs for a combined total power of 20 watts in a svelte little package. The Pacific Sun Triton R2 is a modular LED aquarium fixture with a blend of 10 different LEDs grouped into eight channels of control that is available as either master or slave unit.

Eheim PowerLED vs. Build My LED
Eheim PowerLED has three color combinations — one with all blue diodes, one with a third blue and two thirds white diodes and one with two thirds blue and one third white diodes. With Build My LED you choose your own strip light features, select a preconfigured model or drag-and-drop to create your own from 16 different colors of Philips LumiLED Rebel diodes and then your choice between three different beam angles, all at one low price per length.

Xenoxon CoralStar LED vs. Maxspect Razor 
The Xenoxon Coralstar LED fixtures have some fresh and funky body colors and rely on panels of 1W LED clusters and are also available in a controllable versions. The Maxspect Razor replaced the individually replaceable LEDs with mutliple diode printed circuit boards to make swapping out LEDs much easier. The Razor also has a built-in controller, dual channel control, and six time points per channel to set your lighting schedule.

Giesemann Teszla/Futura vs. Orphek Nilus
The Giesemann Teszla is the basic impressive LED platform from the German lighting giant and the Giesemann Futura is a beefed up, supersized and radio controlled version of the Teszla. The Orphek Nilus is loaded with four LED colors — 30 White LEDs, 22 Blue LEDs, 4 Red LEDs and 4 UV/true violet LEDs — and is rated at 120W, which is more than enough for most reef setups.

Aquatic Life 3W/1W vs. Volx Grassy Solare
The AquaticLife 3W flagship light comes in at a total of 78 watts, made up of white, blue, royal blue and red Cree LEDs. The fixture is fully dimmable and allows up to 18 programmable color combinations, and features like cloud and storm simulation. The Volx Grassy Solare LED has aimed to replicate reef lighting spectrums found at five meters of water clear water and features four colors of blue LEDs.

Veritas Eclipse Smart vs. LEDtric iNSPIRE
The Veritas Controls Eclipse Smart LED has four colors of Cree XP-E and Cree XP-G LEDs (cool white, royal blue, red and green), wireless control, and a mobile application to rule it all. The LEDtric iNSPRE has five colors of LEDs to give you a full spectrum controllable via remote control with 55 LEDs.

Posted in Equipment |
Search More:  
   
  • Ryan

    Just wondering but didnt the radion g2 also release and ship out in 2012?

  • Mike

    Man, didn’t know of half of these LED makers, they say lots of choices benefit the consumer but there is a point of oversaturation.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1723102577 Bobby Melton

    Ha. Let someone else win this year. Next year The Pro is going to take it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/blauaquaristic Blau Aquaristic

    You are facing very different products, Blau Nano LED Lights is only Euro 46 to the public, againts Elos Elite 3 of Euros 395…..it’s like face a 7 year old football player againts a 25 years old professional; maybe the child is very good but it’s near to impossible to win.

  • Tony Gomez

    comparing apples to oranges always turns out well.

  • brett

    lol everyone just votes for the brand they’ve heard of more. almost all the pairings are unknowns against knowns.

  • Mike

    Yes but if 395 Euros worth of Blau Nano lights are better than an Elos Elite 3 it would edge in the favor of the Nano light.

    Eventually there are going to be “mismatches” as “winners” are broken down. Perhaps a better metric would be to compare lights of a particular wattage, i.e. 20 watts and under category, 20-50watts, 50-100 watts, 100-150watts, 150+ watts.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=15706172 Austin Scaccia

    Where are the gen 2 Radions? They came out December 2012. The Radion pros came out Jan 2013.

    It is kinda weird that you did not include one of the most popular entries in the category. It is like telling the Patriots that they will not be playing in the NFL this year so someone else can get a shot.

  • BHazard

    This is the weirdest showdown ever. Most of the fixtures pitted against each other aren’t even comparable in the slightest. $900 fixtures vs $300 ones? 12watts of leds vs 90? huh?

  • thatfoilguy

    Ok so here is my prediction for the Final 4

    Kessil
    Razor
    Mitras
    AI Vega

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/James-Gasta/100000041876809 James Gasta

    Why is the Orphek Nilus even included. This model is no longer available and has been replaced by the new Orphek Atlantik.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002053603852 Michael Hall

    100% agree with all other comments related, good example the new Kid on the block GHL Mitras that is leaps ahead in technology and specifications not to mention obvious price paired with the well known mass market Acan light. Pretty obvious it was not exactly going to go in the Mitras favor. If the Mitras was paired against a lamp at least in the same market arena and price bracket it would have made far more sense, but looking down the list I dont see hardly any that are in the same market group. If an award is going to be handed out at least make it meaningful.

    I think I can see already where this award will be going ;)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/James-Gasta/100000041876809 James Gasta

    Bottom line is do your homework before purchasing any LED pendant. Know the PAR distribution and the spectrum it covers to ensure the spectrum is in the PUR range, the range most corals favorably respond to. I certainly would not use this poll to narrow down my purchase of an LED pendant. As one commenter mentioned, many of the names are unheard of to most people so voters will vote for a name they recognize rather than vote for which one is actually better in performance.

  • Guest

    Thank you all for your support!

  • reefer4life

    The other important thing to understand in a poll of this nature is the fact that people probably voted in every bracket even though they may not have experience or even seen one of the fixtures they are voting for or against.

  • LEDTRiC

    Thank you everyone for your continued support! We greatly appreciate it!